| Place | Swimmer | Age | Club | Time | Std | Power pts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Evan Peters | 19 | NIUN-V | 4:09.84 | — | — |
| 2 | Joseph Swenton | 16 | NICATO | 4:28.86 | A | 584 |
| 3 | George Newsome | 17 | NIVICT | 4:33.05 | A | 551 |
| 1 | Natalie Gilbert | 16 | NIPACK | 4:52.02 | A | 580 |
| 4 | Michael McNelis | 49 | NIUN-0 | 4:56.63 | — | — |
| 2 | Natalie Crossing | 17 | NIVICT | 4:59.86 | — | 536 |
| 3 | Phoebe Risch | 16 | NICLSC | 5:01.46 | A | 527 |
| 1 | Julia Gilbert | 12 | NIPACK | 5:27.13 | BB | 496 |
| 4 | Mila Wilke | 13 | NIVICT | 5:27.34 | BB | 456 |
| 2 | Alyssa Gilbert | 12 | NIPACK | 5:27.60 | BB | 494 |
| 5 | Carlos Santory | 14 | NIRRST | 5:35.34 | — | 341 |
| 5 | Sophie Beikirch | 16 | NIVICT | 5:37.94 | B | 374 |
| 6 | Madeline Paddock | 13 | NIVICT | 5:38.29 | B | 413 |
| 7 | Claire Carmel | 14 | NIVICT | 5:40.85 | B | 380 |
| 3 | Madeline Chabalik | 12 | NIWEBS | 5:43.37 | B | 429 |
| 8 | Grace Northrop | 14 | NIMERC | 5:45.74 | B | 364 |
| 9 | Eleanor Wands | 13 | NICLSC | 5:49.48 | B | 374 |
| 4 | McKayla Hayward | 11 | NIVICT | 6:10.78 | B | 407 |
| 10 | Grace Goodman | — | NISSST | 6:12.87 | — | 285 |
| 1 | Ata Ozgul | — | NIVICT | 6:30.14 | B | — |
| 1 | Olivia Wolfgram | 10 | NIVICT | 6:35.57 | B | — |